For many startup finance hires, a candidate who can grow into the role is the better long-term bet: they stay engaged and tend to stay longer. Test for problem solving, adaptability and work ethic rather than a perfect CV match, and hire a step ahead of where the business is today. Pay for proven experience when the seat needs judgement that is hard to learn on the job, such as commercial decision-making, leading a team or a capital event.
Potential or experience: the honest trade-off
The trade-off is time. An experienced hire is productive sooner and carries less risk in the first months. A hire with potential usually costs less in salary, takes longer to get up to speed, and has more room to grow in the role if it works.
My own lean has been towards potential for a long time. In March 2024, at my previous firm, I wrote that “more often than not, the ideal hire is someone that can grow into the role.” I said then that I was constantly encouraging clients to take the same view, because a candidate still learning the full responsibilities of a role is “more engaged, enthusiastic and more likely to reward the company with longevity and loyalty.”
Founders often reach the same place on their own. As I wrote in March 2026, founders will “back the slightly less experienced person if they're confident they're the better long-term fit.” That is the right instinct for a lot of first finance hires, though some seats do need someone who has held them before.
The searches I run sit at two points in a venture-backed company's life in Australia: when a tech, fintech or deep tech startup brings in its first senior finance person, a head of finance or financial controller around late seed to Series A, and when it appoints its first CFO, somewhere between Series A and Series C.
What to test in the interview instead of the CV
Interviewing for potential means assessing how a person thinks when the answer is not already in their history: how they approach a problem they have not seen, how quickly they learn and how they cope with ambiguity. Past technical work still matters, as evidence of how they learn rather than as a checklist.
| What the CV shows | What to test for instead | |
|---|---|---|
| Skills | A skill set that matches the job description line by line | Problem solving, adaptability and work ethic, which are much harder to teach |
| Credentials | Reporting standards, accounting software and MBAs | Whether you could hand them a problem and not have to worry about it |
| Working style | Technical ability on its own | Independent, proactive and easy to work with in a small team |
| The interview | Technical experience that already looks right on paper | The level of detail in their answers and in their questions |
On a call in May 2026 I put it this way: the skill set gets most of the attention, but more often than not the skill set can be taught. What cannot be taught are things like problem solving, adaptability and work ethic, the intangibles that separate someone excellent from someone who is just okay.
The interview should leave room for that. Preparing a candidate for a CFO interview in March 2026, I told them the interviewer would not be expecting them to know everything straight away, that it was discovery for both parties, and that what would count was the level of detail in their answers and in their questions. My guide to the questions finance candidates ask in an interview covers that from the candidate's side.
The CFO soft skills that decide whether a finance hire works.
Founder fit: ownership, energy and low friction
A first finance hire works directly with a founder who is short on time, on work that rarely arrives in a tidy shape. Fit here means the person takes ownership, needs little direction and adds no friction a small team has to absorb.
In March 2026 a founder told me what they looked for in a finance hire, and it was not technical skills: people who are easy to work with, have good energy, do not cause issues, and are independent and proactive. I called it “the clearest hiring criteria I've heard in ages”, because it gets at the question founders in startups and scale-ups are often really asking: “Can I give this person a problem to solve and not have to worry about them?” In a small team, if someone needs constant direction or is hard to be around, as I wrote then, “your technical skills won't save you.”
Energy is part of the same test. On a CFO search in February 2026, I told a candidate the business needed someone comfortable rolling up their sleeves, because the next 12 to 18 months would take everything the role had. I also said energy, drive and hunger were a big part of it, and that candidates needed to show them, because the growth period and the work to come would demand that energy.
Hire for where the business is going
A future-proofed finance hire is one who can build processes that do not exist yet, rather than repeat what they ran at a mature company. In a fast-growing startup that can mean hiring a little ahead of today's stage.
On a CFO search in July 2026, the business was growing faster than its finance function had kept up with. I described the brief to a candidate as someone probably more capable than where the business was at that point, because finance needed to be set up properly to carry the next period of growth. The same role would cover entry into a new market, and I told the candidate they did not need to have done that exact move before: experience of any new market or new product was what counted.
The question to ask of a candidate's potential is whether it reaches the next stage of the business. My study of Australian startups' first finance hires looks at what happens when a first hire is expected to grow into the CFO seat, and the guide on how to hire a CFO covers pricing the role against the business you will have in a year.
When experience should win
Experience is worth paying for when a mistake in the first year would cost more than the premium, and when the judgement the seat needs takes years to build.
In May 2025, before I started Story, I wrote that when you are hiring you can train processes and upskill people on tools and systems, but some competencies are much harder to develop on the job: commercial decision-making, leading and motivating teams, navigating complex stakeholder environments and translating numbers into strategy.
It is also the client's call, and I respect it. In February 2026, I included candidates on one shortlist who had not yet held a CFO seat, in case the client wanted to consider a rising star profile, while noting that the client had said they wanted someone with more time in the seat. The case for experience gets stronger when a raise, a sale or a listing is close, which my guide on how to hire a CFO covers. The guide to CFO recruitment covers where first CFOs are found, and what makes a great CFO covers how the profile changes with the stage of the business.
The scorecard and interview stages for hiring a startup's first CFO.
Paying for potential: the package and the growth path
A role hired for potential needs a package the business can afford now and a growth path the candidate can see. The path matters as much as the pay.
Budget is often where the conversation starts. In March 2024, at my previous firm, I wrote that when a client's salary is below market I ask what non-cash benefits add to the package, and whether they would consider someone with less experience who can grow into the role, which I called “often the best option for longevity and loyalty.”
On a call with a finance candidate in February 2026, I said the job, the responsibilities, the exposure and where the business was going would probably matter more than the salary. Make those things concrete, and pair them with a plan: in the March 2024 post I quoted at the top of this page, I told candidates to set out what they would do to get up to speed as quickly as possible, and to ask what development support the company had in place. A founder hiring for potential should have that answer ready before the candidate asks. The way to frame the rest of the offer is in my guides to the employee value proposition for a finance hire and the first CFO offer package.
How I run a search for a startup's first finance hire.
Common questions
Should a startup hire for potential or experience in finance?
Often potential: a candidate who can grow into the role tends to be more engaged and more likely to stay. It depends on the next stage of the business. If the seat needs commercial judgement, team leadership or experience of a capital event from day one, a proven candidate is usually the safer choice.
How do you assess potential in a finance candidate?
Test for the things that are hard to teach: problem solving, adaptability and work ethic. Ask how they would approach problems they have not met before, watch the questions they ask about the business, and judge whether you could hand them a problem without having to manage them through it. Skills and systems can usually be taught.
Is a less experienced finance hire cheaper?
Usually the base salary is lower, which is why, when a client's budget is below market, I ask whether they would consider someone who can grow into the role. The cost moves elsewhere: more ramp-up time and a clear development path. On a call with a candidate in February 2026, I said the responsibilities, the exposure and where the business was going would probably matter more than the salary.
When does a startup need a CFO who has done it before?
When the next stage needs judgement that is hard to learn on the job, such as commercial decision-making, leading a team, managing complex stakeholders or taking the business through a raise, sale or listing.
What does hiring ahead of the business stage mean?
It means choosing someone a little more capable than the business needs today, so they can set up the finance function for the next period of growth rather than only run what exists.
These guides set out how we see it, drawn from the searches we run and the finance leaders we work with. They are general information about the market, not financial, accounting or legal advice, and they are no substitute for advice on your own circumstances.
