Skip to content
Story Recruitment
HomeGuidesHiringRecruitmentFinance recruiter
For founders

What a finance recruiter does, and when a startup needs one

A finance recruiter finds, assesses and presents accounting and finance people for an employer, and is paid by that employer, not the candidate. The useful question is not whether to use one. It is which kind, because a high-volume desk and a specialist who runs a handful of searches a month are selling different things.

Hiring a CFO or your first finance lead?

We save what you type here as you go, so we can follow up even if you do not press send. See our privacy policy.

Tom calls you back, usually within one business day. Or call 02 9099 7619.

By Last updated 8 min read

I have recruited accounting and finance people for about ten years, and today I run first-finance-hire and first-CFO searches for venture-backed Australian startups and scale-ups.

A finance recruiter sources and assesses accounting and finance candidates on an employer’s behalf and is paid by the employer. For an Australian startup’s first finance hire or first CFO, use one specialist on retained or exclusive terms, not several generalist agencies.

What a finance recruiter actually does

Strip the job titles away and a finance recruiter does four things. They take a brief from the employer, find people who fit it, assess those people properly, and manage both sides through to a signed contract. The employer pays a fee when the hire is made, or in stages through a retained search. The candidate pays nothing.

The part that varies most is the second one. Some recruiters work the active market: people who have applied to an ad or are already talking to agencies. Others map the whole segment and approach people who are settled and doing well, because for senior finance roles those are usually the people you want. Finding candidates is the easy half of this job. Most people will be looking for a job at some point, so they will take a call. Assessing them properly is where the work is.

A good finance recruiter also argues with you. On the salary, on the title, on whether the role you have written is the role you need. If a recruiter takes your job description without a single question, they are planning to send you CVs.

The businesses I work with don’t want someone to blindly agree with every request. They want honest advice and market insight that helps them make smart, timely hiring decisions.

Which finance roles a finance recruiter places

Across the Australian market, finance recruiters cover the whole ladder: accounts payable and payroll, accountants, financial analysts, finance managers, financial controllers, heads of finance, finance directors and CFOs. Some work on permanent roles, some on contract and temp, and most large agencies run separate desks for each. That breadth is useful when you need throughput on roles with deep candidate pools.

I place two hires, at one kind of company. The first finance hire at an Australian VC-backed startup, usually a head of finance, financial controller or finance manager at roughly 10 to 20 heads and $5-10M ARR or less. And the first CFO, usually at 50-plus heads and $10M-plus ARR. I do not run accountant, bookkeeper, accounts payable or temp roles, and I do not run replacement CFO searches at listed or enterprise companies. Those are real markets with good recruiters in them. They are not mine.

That narrowness is the point. The value is in the niche, because when you are living and breathing one kind of hire all the time you can genuinely add value to the founder and to the candidates. Some of my work comes from other recruiters, who pass a startup finance role to someone who works that space rather than run it themselves.[1] If you are still deciding which first hire you need, a controller or an FP&A lead as the first finance hire is the decision to settle before you brief anyone.

A generalist desk or a specialist: what changes for a startup

Inside a large recruitment firm, each consultant could be working three to ten or more roles at any time. The most common way they split their time is by fillability: whichever role they are most likely to fill gets the hours. In my view, a first finance hire at a 15-person startup, with an unusual brief and equity in the package, rarely wins that contest. It is just me at Story, so I rarely work more than three or four roles a month.

How a generalist agency desk and a specialist startup finance recruiter differ on a first finance hire or first CFO
A generalist agency deskA specialist startup finance recruiter
Time on your role

Shared across three to ten or more live roles, weighted toward the easiest to fill.

A few roles a month, so your search gets the hours a first hire needs.

Who you see

Whoever is active in the market this week and replied first.

A mapped segment, including settled people who would never answer an ad, shortlisted in about five working days.

What arrives

CVs that match the job description.

CVs with a candidate report, and a challenge to the brief before the search starts.

The same logic is why I tell founders to brief one recruiter, not three. Working with several agencies sounds like more candidates. What it actually buys is a varied level of quality, and less time on your role from each of them, because each one’s odds of placing it just fell.

How the two engagement models are paid, and when retained search is worth it over contingent, is worked through separately.

How working with a finance recruiter runs, brief to signed contract

It starts with a brief meeting, and the brief should take longer than you expect. A good one covers the real environment the person is walking into, what is broken, who they report to, the salary and equity, and what the first year has to produce. From there I map the market and talk to people, and the shortlist lands in about five working days: usually four to six candidates.

You get a CV for each, but also a candidate report: what they have done, what they are looking for, and why they are relevant to your role. For a senior finance hire the CV alone tells you very little, and a recruiter who only sends CVs is leaving the assessment to you.

How long the whole search takes depends on the hire, and how long a first CFO or first finance hire search takes is broken down stage by stage, notice period included. Every retained placement carries a six-month replacement guarantee, and 85% of the people I place on retained search are still in the role two years on. Ask any finance recruiter for those same numbers in writing before you sign terms. If they cannot give them to you, they are not measuring their own work.

What a finance recruiter charges in Australia, and how recruitment fees are structured and staged, is covered in full.

If you are a candidate: what a finance recruiter can do for you

A finance recruiter is free to use as a candidate. The employer pays the fee, and several states and territories, including New South Wales, Queensland, Western Australia, South Australia and the ACT, restrict what an agency can charge a job seeker, as the industry body’s code guideline on charging fees to workseekers sets out. What you should expect in return is honest, transparent conversations, help with interview preparation and positioning, and a real read on the business and the leadership team before you meet them.

Expect feedback, too. I have heard plenty of stories of candidates ghosted by recruiters and companies halfway through a process, and a few who heard nothing even after signing a contract. A recruiter worth your time tells you where you stand, including when the answer is no.

The most useful thing you can do before talking to any recruiter is fix your LinkedIn profile. A CV is seen by a handful of people in a week. LinkedIn is where every recruiter, internal talent team, HR lead, hiring manager and CEO goes to search, and they search on keywords and skills. Be specific: the systems you have run, the reporting standards you work under, and technical terms like treasury or securitisation where they are true.

For senior finance candidates, how to work with a finance recruiter from the first call to the offer is set out step by step, and you can register with me directly.

Choosing a finance recruiter in Sydney, Melbourne or anywhere in Australia

Location matters less than segment. A recruiter in your city who places accountants all day knows less about your first CFO hire than a specialist interstate who places nothing else. Ask three things: which roles they have placed in the last year at companies like yours, how many roles each consultant is carrying, and what share of their placements are still in the seat two years later.

I am based in Sydney, and my network of 30,000-plus accounting and finance professionals spans Australia. If you want to compare firms side by side, I have ranked the best finance recruiters in Australia with the scoring shown, and the guide to choosing a financial recruitment agency covers the questions to ask on the first call.

Common questions

What does a finance recruiter do?

A finance recruiter takes a brief from an employer, finds accounting and finance people who fit it, assesses them, presents a shortlist and manages both sides to a signed contract. The employer pays the fee. A specialist also challenges the brief on salary, title and scope before the search starts, and approaches people who are not actively looking.

Is a finance recruiter free for candidates?

Yes. The employer pays the recruitment fee, and several Australian states and territories restrict what an agency can charge a job seeker. What a candidate should expect in return is honest feedback, help preparing for interviews and a clear read on the business before meeting the hiring team.

How long does a finance recruiter take to fill a role?

It depends on the seniority, the model and the candidate's notice period. On my retained searches the shortlist lands in about five working days from the brief meeting, and the average from brief to signed contract is about 22 working days. Ask any recruiter for their own numbers in writing before you sign terms.

Should a startup use a specialist finance recruiter or a large agency?

For high-volume roles with deep candidate pools, a large agency can work well. For a startup's first finance hire or first CFO, use a specialist who places that hire at companies like yours, on retained or exclusive terms. A consultant at a large firm may be carrying three to ten or more roles and will give the most time to whichever is easiest to fill.

Should I brief more than one finance recruiter?

Not for a senior finance hire. Briefing several agencies on the same role means each one's odds of placing it drop, so each gives it less time. You get a wider spread of candidate quality and no one mapping the market properly. Pick one recruiter you trust and hold them to clear numbers.

References

  1. By September 2026, 60% of my client work that year had come through a referral. Some come from founders I have placed a finance leader for, some from vCFOs, VCs and lawyers who sit alongside startups every day, and some from other recruiters who do not work in this space and pass the role to someone who does.

These guides set out how we see it, drawn from the searches we run and the finance leaders we work with. They are general information about the market, not financial, accounting or legal advice, and they are no substitute for advice on your own circumstances.

Hiring your first finance leader?

Tell me the role, the stage and the timeline. I will give you a straight read on the market, including when the search is not one I should run.